The Religion Forum

     Go!
Prospero Blocks


 

Chat Center

All Religion Topcs
Topic: Any topic, any religion.

Board Folders

Christianity: 110303 msgs in 1390 dscns, Latest: 9:08 PMChristianity
110303 msgs in 1390 dscns
Latest: 9:08 PM
Judaism: 26142 msgs in 966 dscns, Latest: Feb-3 Judaism
26142 msgs in 966 dscns
Latest: Feb-3
Eastern Thought: 5272 msgs in 117 dscns, Latest: 8:53 PMEastern Thought
5272 msgs in 117 dscns
Latest: 8:53 PM
Islam: 17368 msgs in 478 dscns, Latest: 10:57 PMIslam
17368 msgs in 478 dscns
Latest: 10:57 PM
Interfaith Issues: 57408 msgs in 808 dscns, Latest: 10:25 PMInterfaith Issues
57408 msgs in 808 dscns
Latest: 10:25 PM
The Public Square: 134617 msgs in 1966 dscns, Latest: 9:24 PMThe Public Square
134617 msgs in 1966 dscns
Latest: 9:24 PM
Global Thought: 19239 msgs in 361 dscns, Latest: Feb-5 Global Thought
19239 msgs in 361 dscns
Latest: Feb-5
Faith and Politics: 8918 msgs in 247 dscns, Latest: 9:54 PMFaith and Poli...
8918 msgs in 247 dscns
Latest: 9:54 PM
Freethinkers: 12717 msgs in 221 dscns, Latest: 9:48 PMFreethinkers
12717 msgs in 221 dscns
Latest: 9:48 PM
Authors Online: 1432 msgs in 69 dscns, Latest: Dec-31 Authors Online
1432 msgs in 69 dscns
Latest: Dec-31
Moral Choices: 4388 msgs in 136 dscns, Latest: 12:28 PMMoral Choices
4388 msgs in 136 dscns
Latest: 12:28 PM
Latter-Day Saints: 22036 msgs in 1386 dscns, Latest: 8:51 PMLatter-Day Saints
22036 msgs in 1386 dscns
Latest: 8:51 PM
Science & Religion: 19561 msgs in 374 dscns, Latest: 11:13 PMScience & Reli...
19561 msgs in 374 dscns
Latest: 11:13 PM
Social Hall: 104598 msgs in 2252 dscns, Latest: 10:57 PMSocial Hall
104598 msgs in 2252 dscns
Latest: 10:57 PM
Message Area
The Public Square

Understanding Scripture - Sniping

 Subscribe SubscribeGet a printer-friendly version of this discussion Print Discussion 

#1 of 171

     Posted Oct-31 9:03 PM   
Tobster E
 
From  Tobster E  Posts 1789  Last Jan-2
To  Gary Z      [Msg # 168398.1 ]    

>>It is my experience that many conservative Christians are taught "what the Bible says" and no mention is made of interpretation. In fact, I've even had some claim that they don't interpret the Bible, they believe what it says. «g»<<

It would help if they would translate the Five Books of Moses accurately from the Hebrew. I do know enough Hebrew to know that there are mistakes.

 OptionsReply to this Message Reply

#2 of 171

     Posted Nov-1 2:00 AM   
Irv & Shoshana Feldman
 
From  Irv & Shoshana Feldman  Posts 4228  Last 1:03 PM
To  Tobster E      [Msg # 168398.2 Message 168398.2 replying to 168398.1 168398.1 ]    (Unread)

>>It is my experience that many conservative Christians are taught "what the Bible says" and no mention is made of interpretation. In fact, I've even had some claim that they don't interpret the Bible, they believe what it says. «g»<

It would help if they would translate the Five Books of Moses accurately from the Hebrew. I do know enough Hebrew to know that there are mistakes.<

The mistakes are more than just mistranslations. There are mistakes due to the way they divided up the sentences and expressions. These weren't always honest mistakes either. They were made on purpose to mislead the ignorant and uneducated.

Irv


Edited Nov-1   by  Irv & Shoshana Feldman
 OptionsReply to this Message Reply

#3 of 171

     Posted Nov-1 6:34 AM   
Omega
 
From  Omega  Posts 16087  Last 6:08 AM
To  Irv & Shoshana Feldman      [Msg # 168398.3 Message 168398.3 replying to 168398.2 168398.2 ]    

>>It would help if they would translate the Five Books of Moses accurately from the Hebrew. I do know enough Hebrew to know that there are mistakes.<<

Our good translations come from a group of scholars who know the Hebrew better than you do.  If you don't know the Hebrew aswell as they do, how do you know that you arfe not the one i n error?

k

 OptionsReply to this Message Reply

#4 of 171

     Posted Nov-1 7:42 AM   
Gary Z
 
From  Gary Z  Posts 11496  Last 5:50 PM
To  Omega      [Msg # 168398.4 Message 168398.4 replying to 168398.3 168398.3 ]    
kermit:
»»   Our good translations come from a group of scholars who know the Hebrew better than you do.

That's a rather bold boast and one that you have absolutely no way of actually knowing as you don't know how well Irv knows Hebrew.  What kind of fruit does that kind of boasting produce, kermit?
Image Hosted by ImageShack.us
 OptionsReply to this Message Reply

#5 of 171

     Posted Nov-1 8:51 AM   
Irv & Shoshana Feldman
 
From  Irv & Shoshana Feldman  Posts 4228  Last 1:03 PM
To  Omega      [Msg # 168398.5 Message 168398.5 replying to 168398.3 168398.3 ]    

>>It would help if they would translate the Five Books of Moses accurately from the Hebrew. I do know enough Hebrew to know that there are mistakes.<

Our good translations come from a group of scholars who know the Hebrew better than you do.  If you don't know the Hebrew aswell as they do, how do you know that you arfe not the one i n error?<

They may know Hebrew better than I but that doesn't mean they uderstand it any better than do our great Jerwish Sages who have been studying the Torah for at least a 1,000 years longer. And beside the studying these Jewish sages have lived it far longer than any Xtian ever could have. Indeed 99 44/100% of the great Jewish Sages got it frm their mother's milk. No Xtian could ever say that or prove it even if his existence wasn't subject to doubt.

Irv



Edited Nov-1   by  Irv & Shoshana Feldman
 OptionsReply to this Message Reply

#6 of 171

     Posted Nov-2 7:03 AM   
Omega
 
From  Omega  Posts 16087  Last 6:08 AM
To  Irv & Shoshana Feldman      [Msg # 168398.6 Message 168398.6 replying to 168398.5 168398.5 ]    

>>They may know Hebrew better than I but that doesn't mean they uderstand it any better than do our great Jerwish Sages who have been studying the Torah for at least a 1,000 years longer.<<

Irrelevant.  Most of the scholars who do Bible translations have spent most of their adult lives studying the language and they also have the benefit the thinking of your great Jewish sages. 

>> And beside the studying these Jewish sages have lived it far longer than any Xtian ever could have. Indeed 99 44/100% of the great Jewish Sages got it frm their mother's milk. No Xtian could ever say that or prove it even if his existence wasn't subject to doubt.<<

First of all living it does not make a good translator.   Only study can do that. You live it but you admit your knowledge is not as good as that of some Christian scholoars.  Some of our sages are converted Jews who also got it from their mothers milk. Again, getting it from one who is not an expert in the language , will not guarentee understanding the languge.  Many who got if from their mothers do not even speak the language.

k

 

 

 

 OptionsReply to this Message Reply

#7 of 171

     Posted Nov-2 10:08 AM   
Irv & Shoshana Feldman
 
From  Irv & Shoshana Feldman  Posts 4228  Last 1:03 PM
To  Omega      [Msg # 168398.7 Message 168398.7 replying to 168398.6 168398.6 ]    

>>They may know Hebrew better than I but that doesn't mean they uderstand it any better than do our great Jerwish Sages who have been studying the Torah for at least a 1,000 years longer.<

Irrelevant.  Most of the scholars who do Bible translations have spent most of their adult lives studying the language and they also have the benefit the thinking of your great Jewish sages. <

It is not irrelevant. They may have spent their lives learning the language but they have never lived the Torah. Aand that makes them less capable of understanding anything written or stated by our Sages who bith knew the language better than anyone else and how the Torah says one should live his or her life. So you can become and expert in Biblical Hebrew. But that will not make any kind of an expert in anything the Torah requires or even suggests without havig lived the Torah way for even 1 day or even an hour.

>> And beside the studying these Jewish sages have lived it far longer than any Xtian ever could have. Indeed 99 44/100% of the great Jewish Sages got it frm their mother's milk. No Xtian could ever say that or prove it even if his existence wasn't subject to doubt.<

First of all living it does not make a good translator.   Only study can do that. You live it but you admit your knowledge is not as good as that of some Christian scholoars.  Some of our sages are converted Jews who also got it from their mothers milk. Again, getting it from one who is not an expert in the language , will not guarentee understanding the languge.  Many who got if from their mothers do not even speak the language.<

So how do you preserve the Sabbath and keep it Holy as it is defined in the Torah? You cam't do by watching or playing football, baseball, tennis or even bowling. You can't do it by going to store because they are having a sale.

Irv


Edited Nov-2   by  Patricia O.
 OptionsReply to this Message Reply

#8 of 171

     Posted Nov-2 1:20 PM   
Martin Alter
 
From  Martin Alter  Posts 1798  Last Feb-7
To  Omega      [Msg # 168398.8 Message 168398.8 replying to 168398.6 168398.6 ]    
>>  

Irrelevant.  Most of the scholars who do Bible translations have spent most of their adult lives studying the language and they also have the benefit the thinking of your great Jewish sages.    <<

Among the most arrogant, insulting and ultimately dangerous aspects of Christianity is the uniquely Christian view that Jews do not know how to interpret, nor do they understand, their own material.  Bishop John Shelby Spong has made this point very strongly in "Rescuing the Bible from Fundamentalism" and in "Liberating the Gospels" Reading the Bible with Jewish Eyes."

The ideas, such as they are, that you routinely express as the perfect examples of such arrogance and would be merely insulting and antisemitic were they not the basis for Christian persecution of Jews over the centuries.  One would hope that such thinking would be gone in the 21st century, but your example demonstrates that such pernicious, dangerous and ignorant ideas about Judaism are thriving among the self-proclaimed theocrats and self-appointed moralists who pretend to know what should or should not be religious dogma.


Edited Nov-2   by  Martin Alter

Edited Nov-2   by  Martin Alter
 OptionsReply to this Message Reply

#9 of 171

     Posted Nov-2 5:05 PM   
Gary Z
 
From  Gary Z  Posts 11496  Last 5:50 PM
To  Irv & Shoshana Feldman      [Msg # 168398.9 Message 168398.9 replying to 168398.7 168398.7 ]    
Irv:
»»   It is not irrelevant. They may have spent their lives learning the language but they have never lived the Torah. Aand that makes them less capable of understanding anything written or stated by our Sages who bith knew the language better than anyone else and how the Torah says one should live his or her life. So you can become and expert in Biblical Hebrew. But that will not make any kind of an expert in anything the Torah requires or even suggests without havig lived the Torah way for even 1 day or even an hour.

Please don't judge all Christians by what some write here.  I, for one, understand exactly what you're saying and I agree with you.
Image Hosted by ImageShack.us
 OptionsReply to this Message Reply

#10 of 171

     Posted Nov-2 8:54 PM   
Irv & Shoshana Feldman
 
From  Irv & Shoshana Feldman  Posts 4228  Last 1:03 PM
To  Gary Z      [Msg # 168398.10 Message 168398.10 replying to 168398.9 168398.9 ]    
»»   It is not irrelevant. They may have spent their lives learning the language but they have never lived the Torah. Aand that makes them less capable of understanding anything written or stated by our Sages who bith knew the language better than anyone else and how the Torah says one should live his or her life. So you can become and expert in Biblical Hebrew. But that will not make any kind of an expert in anything the Torah requires or even suggests without havig lived the Torah way for even 1 day or even an hour.<
Please don't judge all Christians by what some write here.  I, for one, understand exactly what you're saying and I agree with you.<

So why don't you say something to Kermit yourself instead of leaving it to me?   XXXXXXXXXXXXXX

Irv

Edited Nov-2   by  Patricia O.
 OptionsReply to this Message Reply

#11 of 171

     Posted Nov-2 9:09 PM   
Loren
 
From  Loren  Posts 5311  Last 8:18 AM
To  Irv & Shoshana Feldman      [Msg # 168398.11 Message 168398.11 replying to 168398.10 168398.10 ]    

So why don't you say something to Kermit yourself instead of leaving it to me? XXXXXXXXX

Kermit doesn't read Gary's messages, or mine. 

XXXXXXXXXXX

Loren


Edited Nov-2   by  Patricia O.

Edited Nov-2   by  Patricia O.
 OptionsReply to this Message Reply

#12 of 171

     Posted Nov-3 7:04 AM   
Omega
 
From  Omega  Posts 16087  Last 6:08 AM
To  Irv & Shoshana Feldman      [Msg # 168398.12 Message 168398.12 replying to 168398.7 168398.7 ]    

>>It is not irrelevant. They may have spent their lives learning the language but they have never lived the Torah.<<

Livin the Torah is irrelevant to  understand it.  That come only from study and many Jews who live the Torah have not studied it an do not have a good understanding of it.

>> Aand that makes them less capable of understanding anything written or stated by our Sages who bith knew the language better than anyone else and how the Torah says one should live his or her life. So you can become and expert in Biblical Hebrew. But that will not make any kind of an expert in anything the Torah requires or even suggests without havig lived the Torah way for even 1 day or even an hour. <<

That is nonsense.  Not only studying but intense study is the only thing that will help any one understand anything. 

>>So how do you preserve the Sabbath and keep it Holy as it is defined in the Torah? <<

By remembering what God has done for me as described in the Torah---He has sanctified me and freed me from the bondage of the world.  I no longer WORK for my sanctification or for my spiritual freedom.  I remember this every day, not one day a week and that is what keeps it holy.

k

 

 OptionsReply to this Message Reply

#13 of 171

     Posted Nov-3 10:17 AM   
Gary Z
 
From  Gary Z  Posts 11496  Last 5:50 PM
To  Irv & Shoshana Feldman      [Msg # 168398.13 Message 168398.13 replying to 168398.10 168398.10 ]    
Irv:
»»   So why don't you say something to Kermit yourself instead of leaving it to me?

I have, Irv.  Over the years, I have many times.
Image Hosted by ImageShack.us
 OptionsReply to this Message Reply

#14 of 171

     Posted Nov-3 10:24 AM   
Gary Z
 
From  Gary Z  Posts 11496  Last 5:50 PM
To  Omega      [Msg # 168398.14 Message 168398.14 replying to 168398.12 168398.12 ]    
kermit:
»»   Livin the Torah is irrelevant to  understand it.  That come only from study and many Jews who live the Torah have not studied it an do not have a good understanding of it.»»   That is nonsense.  Not only studying but intense study is the only thing that will help any one understand anything. 

What you are arguing is that book learning is as good as experience.  That's nonsense, kermit.

If you needed to fly somewhere and you have the choice of two airplanes; one piloted by an experienced pilot and the other by a guy who had read a bunch of books on the subject of piloting an airplane, which one would you choose?

There is no substitute for experience.
Image Hosted by ImageShack.us
 OptionsReply to this Message Reply

#15 of 171

     Posted Nov-3 12:51 PM   
Patricia O.
 
From  Patricia O.  Posts 11797  Last 12:08 PM
To  Omega      [Msg # 168398.15 Message 168398.15 replying to 168398.12 168398.12 ]    
>>> That is nonsense.  Not only studying but intense study is the only thing that will help any one understand anything. <<<
Interesting how you believe that to be true of Jewish scripture, but not of Christian scripture.   Have you not said numerous times that many of us can never understand the Bible because we're not believers?
 OptionsReply to this Message Reply

#16 of 171

     Posted Nov-3 3:29 PM   
Irv & Shoshana Feldman
 
From  Irv & Shoshana Feldman  Posts 4228  Last 1:03 PM
To  Omega      [Msg # 168398.16 Message 168398.16 replying to 168398.12 168398.12 ]    

>>It is not irrelevant. They may have spent their lives learning the language but they have never lived the Torah.<

Living the Torah is irrelevant to  understand it.  That come only from study and many Jews who live the Torah have not studied it an do not have a good understanding of it.<

If you never got married how could you understand what married life is like?

>> And that makes them less capable of understanding anything written or stated by our Sages who bith knew the language better than anyone else and how the Torah says one should live his or her life. So you can become and expert in Biblical Hebrew. But that will not make any kind of an expert in anything the Torah requires or even suggests without havig lived the Torah way for even 1 day or even an hour. <

That is nonsense.  Not only studying but intense study is the only thing that will help any one understand anything. <

It is non-sense and you know it. Do you what ids like to be a Muslim? Do you know what it is like to be a Taoist? You don't and you can't possibly know it without having lived it. So stop trying to make stuff up.

>>So how do you preserve the Sabbath and keep it Holy as it is defined in the Torah? <

By remembering what God has done for me as described in the Torah---He has sanctified me and freed me from the bondage of the world.  I no longer WORK for my sanctification or for my spiritual freedom.  I remember this every day, not one day a week and that is what keeps it holy.<

Aren't we getting a little full of ourself here? One can never reach the point where one no longer has to work at waht we believe. XXXXXXXXXXXXXX

Irv


Edited Nov-3   by  Patricia O.
 OptionsReply to this Message Reply

#17 of 171

     Posted Nov-3 3:30 PM   
Irv & Shoshana Feldman
 
From  Irv & Shoshana Feldman  Posts 4228  Last 1:03 PM
To  Gary Z      [Msg # 168398.17 Message 168398.17 replying to 168398.13 168398.13 ]    
»»   So why don't you say something to Kermit yourself instead of leaving it to me?
I have, Irv.  Over the years, I have many times.<

I was not aware if that.

Irv
 OptionsReply to this Message Reply

#18 of 171

     Posted Nov-4 5:10 AM   
Omega
 
From  Omega  Posts 16087  Last 6:08 AM
To  Patricia O.      [Msg # 168398.18 Message 168398.18 replying to 168398.15 168398.15 ]    

>>Interesting how you believe that to be true of Jewish scripture, but not of Christian scripture. <<

In Christsianity there is no such thing as Jewish Scripture and Christian Scripture.  There is only Scripture.

>>  Have you not said numerous times that many of us can never understand the Bible because we're not believers?<<

That is what the Bible says(I Cor 2:14).  It is based on the fact that only God's Holy Spirit can reveal spiritual truth to anyone, including Christians and non-believers do not have the indwelling of the Holy Spirit.

That does not mean non-belivers can't understand the basic, literal  meaning of a verse.  Certainly anyone with even a 8th grade reading comprehension can udnderstand what "Jesus died and rose on the third day" means.  However because they don't believe it to be true, they can't understand the spiritual truth(s) it represents.

k


Edited Nov-4   by  Omega
 OptionsReply to this Message Reply

#19 of 171

     Posted Nov-4 8:24 AM   
Irv & Shoshana Feldman
 
From  Irv & Shoshana Feldman  Posts 4228  Last 1:03 PM
To  Omega      [Msg # 168398.19 Message 168398.19 replying to 168398.18 168398.18 ]    

>>Interesting how you believe that to be true of Jewish scripture, but not of Christian scripture. <

In Christsianity there is no such thing as Jewish Scripture and Christian Scripture.  There is only Scripture.<

I other words, there is no Jewish version as the only valid one, in your NOT so humble opinion, is the result of mistranslations and purposely created myths. How liberal of you.


>>  Have you not said numerous times that many of us can never understand the Bible because we're not believers?<

That is what the Bible says(I Cor 2:14).  It is based on the fact that only God's Holy Spirit can reveal spiritual truth to anyone, including Christians and non-believers do not have the indwelling of the Holy Spirit.<

Only your mistranslated and ttaly ludicrous version says that. I don't see it in mine, the valid one, since it was written by Hashem and not some charlattan pretending to be Hashem..

>That does not mean non-belivers can't understand the basic, literal  meaning of a verse.  Certainly anyone with even a 8th grade reading comprehension can understand what "Jesus died and rose on the third day" means.  However because they don't believe it to be true, they can't understand the spiritual truth(s) it represents.<

And that is exactly why a non-Jew can't understand the truth when it as plain as day.

Irv


Edited Nov-4   by  Ivy [Staff]
 OptionsReply to this Message Reply

#20 of 171

     Posted Nov-4 11:46 AM   
Mel [Staff]
 
From  Mel [Staff]  Posts 19516  Last 11:22 PM
To  Omega      [Msg # 168398.20 Message 168398.20 replying to 168398.18 168398.18 ]    

>>In Christsianity there is no such thing as Jewish Scripture and Christian Scripture.  There is only Scripture.<<

So in Christianity, the Book of Mormon is considered scripture?
 
 OptionsReply to this Message Reply
 Subscribe SubscribeGet a printer-friendly version of this discussion Print Discussion 
The Public Square

Understanding Scripture - Sniping

  
 
     

Welcome, Guest

  • Post a message
  • New messages to you
  • Log in

Start Search
Advanced Search

Prospero Blocks
 
 
Special Offers
 
 
 

Cool Clicks!

 
 
 

Finding People

 
 
 
© 2009 Netscape Communications Corp. All rights reserved.

Legal Notices | Privacy Policy